Enhanced rock weathering spreads crushed silicate minerals across agricultural land to accelerate the natural process by which CO₂ is absorbed into carbonate minerals. Marine carbon dioxide removal dissolves alkaline materials in the ocean to increase its CO₂ uptake. Both are proposed as large-scale negative emissions technologies. Both require covering enormous surface areas.
Note (2026-11-14; read against the paper's full text): the essay says the net effect can be warming in some configurations and that deploying carbon removal can make the planet warmer. The paper's statement is about the albedo forcing alone: its sign depends on the material and the soil it is applied to (dark mafic and ultramafic rocks such as basalt or peridotite may decrease soil albedo and contribute to warming, whereas whitish minerals such as wollastonite should increase the reflectance and cool), and the albedo forcing can dominate over the CO2 removal for years or decades after treatment, until enough CO2 has been absorbed. It uses simple estimates with typical albedo changes of 1 to 10 percent and assumes the forcing is mixed globally, and it describes its list of questions as open. For the ocean it says how changes in surface waters might alter the albedo is unclear (seawater has low albedo, so even added ultramafic minerals could brighten the sea surface), and it lists surface blooms of diatoms or algae and dimethyl sulfide from marine organisms as possible albedo effects to be studied; the essay states the ocean albedo change without that uncertainty.
Marston and Ibarra (arXiv:2501.01885) show that both approaches change Earth's albedo — the fraction of sunlight reflected back to space — and the albedo change can overwhelm the radiative forcing from the CO₂ removed.
The mechanism is straightforward. Spreading light-colored crushed rock over dark agricultural soil increases land albedo, producing a cooling effect independent of any carbon removal. Conversely, changing ocean surface chemistry can alter ocean albedo. The radiative impact of even parts-per-thousand changes in albedo across millions of square kilometers is comparable to removing substantial quantities of atmospheric CO₂.
The problem: the albedo effect operates immediately, while the CO₂ removal effect accumulates slowly. In the early years and potentially decades of deployment, the albedo change dominates the total radiative balance. For some configurations — particularly land-based enhanced weathering in certain regions — the net effect can be warming, not cooling. You deploy a carbon removal technology and the planet gets warmer.
The structural insight: large-scale surface modifications cannot be evaluated by their intended mechanism alone. Any technology that covers millions of square kilometers of Earth's surface is, whether it intends to be or not, a geoengineering intervention with albedo consequences. The carbon removal is one effect among several, and it may not be the largest one.
Marston & Ibarra, "Removing Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide Using Large Land Or Ocean Areas Will Change Earth Albedo And Force Climate," arXiv:2501.01885 (2025).