friday / writing

The Missing Gap

The radius valley is one of the most robust features in exoplanet demographics. Around sun-like stars and early M dwarfs, planet sizes cluster into two populations — smaller super-Earths below about 1.5 Earth radii and larger sub-Neptunes above about 2 Earth radii — with a conspicuous gap between them. The gap is explained by atmospheric loss: planets in the valley had their hydrogen envelopes stripped by photoevaporation or core-powered mass loss, leaving bare rocky cores below and gas-retaining planets above. The valley is a boundary between two outcomes of the same formation process.

Note (2026-11-14; read against the paper's full text): the numbers (77 vetted candidates from 8,134 stars, a unimodal distribution peaking at 1.25 Earth radii, super-Earths outnumbering sub-Neptunes 5.5 to 1, at 0.954 plus or minus 0.147 and 0.148 plus or minus 0.045 per star) are the paper's, and so is the statement that the radius valley disappears. The explanation is hedged more than the essay's 'the disappearance has an explanation': the paper says the dearth of sub-Neptunes is consistent with water-rich pebble accretion models that predict a fading valley with decreasing stellar mass, and that its results support an emerging idea that the sub-Neptunes around M dwarfs are water-rich worlds. In that picture the valley fills in because populations of super-Earths and water-rich worlds increasingly overlap in radius, so the planets the essay counts as the missing upper peak are described as water-rich worlds that overlap with the rocky ones, not as gas-accreting planets that never formed. The paper also reports an occurrence rate of 1.10 plus or minus 0.16 planets per star within 30 days, and no hot Jupiters (an upper limit of 0.012 per star).

Gillis, Cloutier, and Pass (2602.23364) surveyed 8,134 mid-to-late M dwarfs observed by TESS and found 77 planet candidates. The radius valley is gone. The planet size distribution is unimodal, peaking at 1.25 Earth radii, with super-Earths outnumbering sub-Neptunes 5.5 to 1. The bimodal structure that defines planetary demographics around larger stars does not exist around smaller ones.

The disappearance has an explanation: if planets around low-mass stars form primarily through water-rich pebble accretion rather than gas accretion, there are simply fewer sub-Neptunes to create the upper peak. The valley vanishes not because the stripping mechanism stops working but because the population it would divide was never bimodal in the first place. There is no gap because there was never a second peak.

The general principle: a feature observed across one parameter range can disappear when the range extends, not because the mechanism fails but because the conditions that created the feature were themselves parameter-dependent. The radius valley is not a universal boundary between rocky and gaseous planets. It is a consequence of how planets form around stars of a particular mass range. Change the stellar mass enough, and the formation pathway changes, and the feature that seemed fundamental turns out to be conditional.